OSEP Discipline Guidance and the Manifestation Determination Review: What Still Applies
The July 2022 Guidance Package
In July 2022, the Office of Special Education and Rehabilitative Services (OSERS) and the Office for Civil Rights (OCR) released a joint discipline guidance package addressing how IDEA and Section 504 apply to school discipline of students with disabilities. It was the most comprehensive federal statement on the topic in years.
The guidance addressed several practices that parents and advocates had been fighting about for decades — particularly the use of informal removals and the obligation to provide behavioral supports before resorting to exclusion.
What the 2022 Guidance Clarified
Repeated Informal Removals May Count as Disciplinary Removals
The July 2022 OSEP Q&A explains that repeated informal exclusions — such as shortened school days — may constitute disciplinary removals. It considers whether the student continues to participate appropriately in the general curriculum, receive IEP services, and participate with nondisabled peers to the extent required by the student's placement. Not every early pickup or shortened day automatically counts as a removal.
The Q&A applies the existing IDEA rules to repeated informal exclusions; it does not make every behavior-based exclusion an automatic change of placement.
Discipline Should Not Substitute for Appropriate Supports
The guidance stated that schools should not use discipline as a substitute for providing appropriate behavioral supports or for conducting functional behavioral assessments and developing behavior intervention plans. Under IDEA, when behavior is found to be a manifestation, the IEP Team must conduct an FBA unless one was already conducted and implement a BIP, or review and modify an existing BIP as needed. The child returns to the prior placement unless a special-circumstances removal applies or the parent and LEA agree otherwise.
Section 504 Discipline Standards
The OCR component addressed Section 504 discipline in detail, clarifying that a long-term exclusion or a pattern of short-term removals constitutes a "significant change in placement" requiring a manifestation determination under 34 CFR 104.35. OCR described the evaluation as examining whether the behavior was caused by or had a direct and substantial relationship to the student's disability — and if so, whether placement changes are needed to provide FAPE.
What Changed Under the Current Administration
Since the guidance was issued, the regulatory landscape has shifted. The Department of Education's approach to sub-regulatory guidance has changed, and the July 24, 2026 final rule amended 34 CFR Part 100 to eliminate Title VI disparate-impact liability.
Here is what parents need to understand about what this means — and what it does not mean.
What Did Not Change
The statutes are intact. IDEA (20 U.S.C. 1415(k)) and its implementing regulations (34 CFR 300.530 through 300.536) carry the force of law. They were enacted by Congress and can only be changed by Congress. No executive action, guidance withdrawal, or agency reorganization alters these statutory requirements:
- An MDR is required when a disciplinary removal is more than 10 consecutive school days, or when a series of removals totaling more than 10 school days forms a pattern under 34 CFR 300.536
- The two statutory questions still must be answered
- Manifestation findings require an FBA unless one was already conducted, implementation of a BIP or review and modification of an existing BIP, and return to the prior placement unless a special-circumstances removal applies or the parent and LEA agree otherwise
- After 10 cumulative removal days, services are required as specified in 34 CFR 300.530(d); during the first 10 days, services are required only if the school provides them to similarly situated students without disabilities
- Parents still have the right to expedited due process hearings
- Section 504's prohibition on disability discrimination in federally funded programs remains in effect
The same applies to 34 CFR Part 104 (Section 504). These are federal regulations with the force of law — not guidance documents that can be withdrawn.
What May Have Changed
Sub-regulatory guidance — Dear Colleague Letters, policy documents, Q&A publications, fact sheets — represents the agency's enforcement posture. It indicates how the Department will investigate complaints and what it considers a violation. Withdrawals of guidance can change enforcement priorities without changing the underlying law.
What this means in practice: if you file an OCR complaint about informal removals, the agency's willingness to investigate may differ from what the 2022 guidance described. But the underlying legal obligation on the school has not changed. The school must still comply with 34 CFR 300.530 and 34 CFR 104.35, and a hearing officer applying the statute will evaluate the same legal standards regardless of agency guidance.
Free Download
Get the Manifestation Determination Meeting Checklist
Everything in this article as a printable checklist — plus action plans and reference guides you can start using today.
A.J.T. v. Osseo Area Schools (June 2025)
One significant judicial development since the guidance: in June 2025, the Supreme Court held that students bringing ADA and Section 504 claims about educational services need not meet the heightened "bad faith or gross misjudgment" standard; the same standards that apply in other disability-discrimination contexts govern. The case concerned denied instructional accommodations, not disciplinary removals. The Court described a majority of circuit courts as allowing deliberate-indifference proof for damages, but it did not decide every circuit's damages standard.
For parents navigating MDRs, A.J.T. removes a heightened education-specific standard for educational-services claims. It does not by itself establish that a school owes damages for a particular disciplinary decision; a damages claim still depends on the applicable standard for intentional discrimination and the facts.
What This Means for Your MDR
Whether the 2022 guidance is in effect, partially withdrawn, or fully rescinded, the rights it described come from the statute — not from the guidance itself. When you walk into an MDR meeting:
- The school must still review "all relevant information in the student's file"
- The team must still answer both statutory questions
- Repeated informal removals may count toward the removal analysis; whether they are disciplinary removals depends on the conditions and pattern described in the IDEA discipline rules
- Implementation failures still trigger a manifestation finding under 34 CFR 300.530(e)(1)(ii)
If the school says "that guidance was withdrawn" as a reason to skip procedures, point them to the regulation. The regulation has not been withdrawn.
Our Manifestation Determination Review Guide cites the statutory and regulatory sources — not the guidance documents — so the legal framework you are working from is durable regardless of which administration is in office.
Get Your Free Manifestation Determination Meeting Checklist
Download the Manifestation Determination Meeting Checklist — a printable guide with checklists, scripts, and action plans you can start using today.