Manifestation Determination Review Questions to Ask at the Meeting
Asking the Right Questions Changes the Meeting
An MDR meeting can move fast. The school team has done this before, they control the room, and they have already reviewed the file. Many parents sit through the meeting reacting to what the school presents rather than directing the conversation toward the evidence that matters. Asking specific, targeted questions shifts the dynamic — it forces the team to address the statutory requirements and creates a record of what was and was not considered.
Under 34 CFR 300.530(e)(1), the team must review "all relevant information in the student's file." Your questions ensure that review actually happens rather than being reduced to a summary by the special education coordinator.
Before the Meeting Starts
"What records are being reviewed today?" The team is required to review the IEP, teacher observations, and any relevant information provided by the parents. Ask them to list the specific documents on the table. If they have not pulled the behavior intervention plan, the most recent evaluation, or the service delivery logs, request that those be added to the review before any discussion begins.
"Did you receive the documentation I submitted?" If you sent a written evidence packet before the meeting, confirm it was distributed to all team members. If the school coordinator has it but other team members have not seen it, ask for time to review it at the table.
"Who determined the team composition?" Under the statute, relevant team members are determined by the parent and the LEA together. If you and the LEA agreed that a specific person should attend — the child's general education teacher, their behavioral specialist, a therapist — and that person is not present, note that on the record and ask why.
During Question 1: The Disability-Behavior Relationship
"What specific disability-related deficits are being considered in relation to this behavior?" This question forces the team to look at the child's actual functional profile — not just the disability label. If the team is treating a diagnosis of ADHD as a checkbox rather than examining how impaired impulse control or executive dysfunction operated at the time of the incident, this question redirects them.
"What was happening in the child's environment immediately before the incident?" Antecedent conditions matter. If the behavior occurred during a transition, in a noisy environment, after a denied accommodation, or during an unstructured period — all of which can trigger disability-related responses — the team needs to consider those factors.
"What does the evaluation say about the child's capacity to regulate this type of behavior?" Point the team to specific findings in the psychoeducational evaluation. If the evaluation documents impaired response inhibition, sensory processing difficulties, or emotional dysregulation, those findings are directly relevant to whether the behavior had a direct and substantial relationship to the disability.
Free Download
Get the Manifestation Determination Meeting Checklist
Everything in this article as a printable checklist — plus action plans and reference guides you can start using today.
During Question 2: Failure to Implement the IEP
"Was the BIP being followed on the day of the incident?" If the behavior intervention plan specifies de-escalation steps, sensory breaks, or specific adult responses to behavioral triggers, ask the team to confirm whether those supports were in place. Ask for the specific staff member who was responsible and whether they were aware of the BIP requirements.
"Can you show me the service delivery logs for the past 30 days?" If the IEP requires speech therapy twice a week and the logs show missed sessions, or if the BIP requires a check-in with the counselor each morning and no logs exist, that is an implementation gap. The team must consider whether the school's failure to deliver mandated services contributed to the behavior.
"Were all accommodations from the IEP in effect during the class period when the incident occurred?" This gets granular. If the IEP specifies preferential seating, a fidget tool, extended time on transitions, or a visual schedule — was each one in place that day, in that period, with that teacher?
After the Determination
"What is the basis for the finding?" Whether the team finds manifestation or not, ask them to state the specific evidence and reasoning behind the decision. This creates a record for any future appeal.
"Will the school issue Prior Written Notice for its proposed or refused action?" Under 34 CFR 300.503, PWN is required when the school proposes or refuses to change identification, evaluation, educational placement, or FAPE. If the MDR participants cannot reach consensus, the LEA must make the determination and provide PWN. Ask which action the school is taking and when you will receive the notice.
"What are my appeal rights and the timeline?" The school should inform you of your right to an expedited due process hearing under 34 CFR 300.532 — hearing within 20 school days, decision within 10 school days. If they do not raise this, ask directly.
The MDR Guide for Parents includes a structured question framework organized around both statutory questions, plus a meeting notes template that helps you document answers in real time so the record is complete before you leave the room.
Get Your Free Manifestation Determination Meeting Checklist
Download the Manifestation Determination Meeting Checklist — a printable guide with checklists, scripts, and action plans you can start using today.