Katie Beckett Georgia Cost Effectiveness: How the Home vs. Institution Test Works
The Test Georgia Runs Before Approving Coverage
Even after your child meets the disability standard and the institutional level of care criteria, Georgia runs one more gate: cost effectiveness. Under 42 CFR § 435.225, the state must establish that caring for your child at home through Medicaid will cost no more than placing them in the institutional setting they clinically qualify for.
This isn't optional. A child who is clearly disabled and clearly needs institutional-level care can still be denied Katie Beckett if the projected home care costs exceed the institutional benchmark.
How the Comparison Works
Alliant Health Solutions determines the level of care. DFCS then compares the physician's estimate on the DMA-704 Cost-Effectiveness Form with DCH's monthly Medicaid rate for the institution matching that level of care. The comparison pairs two numbers:
Projected home care costs — the physician's estimate of Medicaid services needed at home. The DMA-704 form lists physician services, durable medical equipment, drugs, therapies, skilled nursing, and other services.
Institutional benchmark cost — the average Medicaid reimbursement rate for the type of facility your child's level of care qualifies them for. The benchmark depends on which institutional standard was met:
- Hospital level of care: benchmarked against the hospital rate, the highest of the three in DCH's 2026 chart: $185,883 for 31 days
- Nursing facility (NF) level of care: benchmarked against the skilled nursing facility rate, $8,455 for 31 days in DCH's 2026 chart
- ICF/ID level of care: benchmarked against the ICF/ID rate, $28,701 for 31 days in DCH's 2026 chart; this is above skilled nursing and below hospital
If projected home costs are at or below the institutional benchmark, the application passes the cost-effectiveness gate. If home costs exceed the benchmark, the application is denied on cost-ineffectiveness grounds.
Why the Level of Care Category Matters for Cost Effectiveness
The institutional benchmark your child is measured against directly determines how much room exists in the cost-effectiveness calculation. Hospital-level benchmarks are substantially higher than ICF/IID benchmarks, so a child who qualifies at the hospital level has a wider margin.
This creates a practical issue for children who qualify through the ICF/ID pathway (common for autism, Down syndrome, and other intellectual/developmental disabilities). The ICF/ID benchmark is lower than the hospital benchmark but higher than skilled nursing, meaning projected home care costs have to be compared with the rate for the child's approved level of care.
Children who qualify through the nursing facility pathway (common for cerebral palsy, spina bifida, and complex medical conditions requiring skilled nursing) do not necessarily have more room: DCH's 2026 chart lists a lower skilled nursing rate than the ICF/ID rate.
Free Download
Get the Georgia — Katie Beckett Application Checklist
Everything in this article as a printable checklist — plus action plans and reference guides you can start using today.
What to Do if Cost Effectiveness Is Close
The Cost Effectiveness Form asks for projected service utilization. Families don't control the Medicaid reimbursement rates, but the projected hours and frequency of services on the form directly drive the home-cost total.
If the initial calculation comes in over the benchmark, families can present adjusted service structures during an administrative reconsideration. This might mean demonstrating that certain therapy goals can be met with fewer weekly sessions or that some equipment needs are one-time purchases rather than ongoing costs. DCH policy directs DFCS to consider health or long-term-care insurance and to exclude GAPP services or costs from the comparison.
This is not about asking for less care — it's about accurately documenting what Medicaid would actually pay for versus what other systems (the school district, private insurance as primary) already cover.
The Practical Takeaway
The cost-effectiveness test is mechanical, not subjective. It compares two dollar figures. Understanding which institutional benchmark applies to your child and what drives the home-cost projection gives you a clear picture of where you stand before submitting.
Our Georgia Katie Beckett Medicaid Guide breaks down the cost-effectiveness calculation step by step, including how each level of care maps to its institutional benchmark and strategies for structuring the Cost Effectiveness Form when the numbers are tight.
Get Your Free Georgia — Katie Beckett Application Checklist
Download the Georgia — Katie Beckett Application Checklist — a printable guide with checklists, scripts, and action plans you can start using today.