School Demanding a Private Assessment Before Supporting Your Child in South Africa

The school tells you that before they can put anything in place, you need to get your child assessed by a private educational psychologist. The cost is somewhere between R6,000 and R7,000. You do not have that money. Or maybe you do, but you suspect the school is using this as a way to delay the process indefinitely.

You are right to be suspicious. In most cases, this demand is unlawful.

What the Law Actually Says

The SIAS policy (Government Gazette 38357, 2014) does not require a private diagnostic assessment before a school initiates support. The process starts with the teacher observing a learning barrier and completing Support Needs Assessment Form 1 (SNA 1) — a document the teacher is supposed to fill in based on classroom observation, not an external diagnosis.

The legal obligation to initiate screening sits with the school, not with the parent. Schools that tell you "we need the report first" have inverted the legal burden. The SIAS process is precisely what is supposed to generate the evidence base for support — private assessments are not a prerequisite for the SNA 1 or SNA 2 process.

Under the Promotion of Equality and Prevention of Unfair Discrimination Act (PEPUDA), demanding that a parent pay thousands of rands for a private report before the school will fulfil its statutory obligations is a barrier to reasonable accommodation — which constitutes unfair discrimination on the basis of disability.

When Is a Private Assessment Legitimately Useful?

There are situations where a private psycho-educational assessment genuinely helps the advocacy process, even if it is not legally required to start it:

• Matric concessions: For NSC examination accommodations (extra time, a scribe, a separate venue), the District-Based Accommodations Committee requires a psycho-educational report with historical evidence of the barrier. If your child is in high school and approaching the Grade 10 application deadline, a private report becomes strategically important — not because the school is entitled to demand it, but because the matric concession system requires it.

• DBST referrals for special school placement: A private educational psychologist report that completes the specific DBE diagnostic annexures (Annexure D / DBE Form 126) carries weight in a DBST assessment and can accelerate the placement process for a child with high support needs.

• Overriding a stalled school process: If the SBST is completing SNA 1 and 2 superficially and downplaying the child's needs, a thorough private report gives you documented external evidence to push back against the school's assessment.

But in all these cases, the parent is choosing to pursue a private assessment strategically, not complying with an unlawful demand from the school.

When the School Is Using the Assessment Demand as a Stalling Tactic

Schools know that R6,000 to R7,000 is a significant barrier for most families. Demanding a private assessment before providing any support is a well-documented way to delay the process, particularly for children whose behaviour is challenging but whose families cannot afford to pay.

If your school has told you they need a private report before they can help, ask them to put that statement in writing and identify the specific policy clause that requires it. They will not be able to, because no such clause exists. That written demand — or the refusal to provide it in writing — becomes part of your formal documentation.

Once you have that, your next step is a formal letter to the principal and SBST coordinator citing the SIAS policy and requesting the initiation of SNA 1 within 10 school days. Copy the District Director. At that point the school must either comply or produce a formal, documented reason for refusing — which opens the door to a DBST complaint.

What if the DBST Assessment Queue Is Years Long?

The DBST is supposed to conduct its own assessments at no cost to families. In practice, backlogs in provinces like Gauteng and KwaZulu-Natal mean free DBST assessments can take 18 months or more. This is a genuine problem, and it is why some families choose to pay for private assessments even when they do not have to.

If you are pursuing the public route, you can request in writing that the DBST provide a timeline for their assessment and deploy interim support — ideally through the school's SBST-driven ISP — while the assessment is pending. The DBST cannot simply place your child in a queue with no interim plan.

If cost is the deciding factor in whether you pursue a private assessment, contact the Equal Education Law Centre (EELC) at 021 461 1421 or [email protected]. They provide free legal services to families facing systemic educational exclusions and can advise on whether the school's demand gives grounds for an SAHRC complaint.

The Right Sequence

The correct order is:

1. School identifies a learning barrier and initiates SNA 1 (no private assessment required)
2. SBST meets, develops an ISP with SNA 2 (no private assessment required)
3. If external assessment adds value — for matric concessions or DBST referral — the parent submits DBE Form 126 completed by any registered professional, public or private

At no point is a private educational psychologist report the legal gatekeeper to the process. If a school is treating it as one, that is the specific issue to challenge.

The South Africa SIAS & Inclusive Education Blueprint walks through each stage of the SIAS process in plain language, including letter templates for demanding the process be initiated and for formally disputing a school's unlawful assessment demand.

See more South Africa guides →