Independent Educational Evaluation in Tennessee: Your Right, The School's Obligation

The school ran a psychoeducational evaluation on your child. You read the results and something feels wrong — maybe the scores don't match what you see at home, or the evaluator missed an obvious area, or the conclusion that your child doesn't have a disability contradicts a private diagnosis. You're not required to simply accept the school's findings.

Tennessee law, following federal IDEA requirements, gives you the right to request an Independent Educational Evaluation (IEE) at the school district's expense.

What an IEE Is

An Independent Educational Evaluation is an evaluation conducted by a qualified professional who is not employed by the school district that evaluated your child. The key phrase is "at public expense" — meaning the district pays for it, not you.

You can request an IEE whenever you disagree with the results or methods of any evaluation the school has conducted. You don't have to prove the school was wrong. Disagreement alone is sufficient to trigger the process.

What the School Must Do Next

Once you submit a written IEE request, the district faces a strict binary choice under Tennessee State Board Rule 0520-01-09:

Option A: The district agrees to fund the IEE. They must then provide you with a list of independent evaluators who meet their qualifications criteria, along with the location parameters for where the evaluation can be conducted.

Option B: The district files for due process to defend its evaluation. The district must initiate this action "without unnecessary delay" — it cannot sit on your request. An Administrative Law Judge then determines whether the school's original evaluation was legally and procedurally appropriate.

The school cannot do a third thing: they cannot ignore your request, stall indefinitely, or tell you to reconsider. Once the request is submitted in writing, the clock runs.

How to Request an IEE

Submit your request in writing. You can send it by email (with a read receipt) or certified mail to the special education director at your local education agency (LEA). Your letter should be brief and direct:

"I disagree with the results of [name of evaluation] conducted on [date]. I am requesting an Independent Educational Evaluation at public expense under IDEA and Tennessee special education regulations."

You do not need to explain why you disagree in detail. Keep the letter short and formal.

Criteria and Qualifications

The district can set reasonable qualification criteria for IEE evaluators — for example, that they hold appropriate licensure, have relevant experience, or are located within a certain geographic area. However, these criteria cannot be so narrow that they effectively prevent you from obtaining an IEE. If you want to use an evaluator you've already found who doesn't meet all district criteria, you have the right to ask the district to justify each criterion.

If the district agrees to pay for an IEE but you choose to use an evaluator who does not meet their criteria and they refuse to fund it, you still have the right to obtain that evaluation at your own expense and submit the results to the IEP team.

What Areas Can Be Independently Evaluated

Any assessment the school has conducted is eligible for an IEE. Common areas include:

• Psychoeducational evaluations (cognitive/academic)
• Speech-language assessments
• Occupational therapy evaluations
• Behavioral assessments
• Assistive technology evaluations
• Functional behavioral assessments (FBAs)

You can request an IEE for one specific area or for a comprehensive re-evaluation across multiple domains. Be specific in your request about which evaluation(s) you're challenging.

What Happens with the IEE Results

The IEP team must consider the IEE results. "Consider" has a legal meaning here — it does not mean they must agree with every finding or recommendation, but it does mean they must review the findings at a meeting and address them substantively. They cannot ignore an IEE.

If the independent evaluator recommends additional services, a different placement, or a revised eligibility determination, the team must discuss those recommendations. If the team disagrees with the IEE findings, they must document their reasons for rejecting them.

This is where an IEE becomes strategically powerful: it shifts the burden. Instead of a single school-employed evaluator's conclusion, the team now has competing expert opinions to reconcile. A well-conducted IEE from a respected independent evaluator makes it significantly harder for a district to justify denying services.

IEEs in the Context of Tennessee's RTI² Framework

Tennessee's Response to Instruction and Intervention (RTI²) framework adds a layer of complexity to evaluation disputes. Some districts use RTI² data as the primary basis for determining that a child does not have a Specific Learning Disability — citing that the student is responding to Tier II or Tier III interventions and therefore does not meet the adverse-impact threshold.

If you believe the RTI² data is inaccurate, incomplete, or being interpreted incorrectly, you can request an IEE of the school's data collection methodology and intervention fidelity. An independent evaluator can assess whether interventions were implemented as designed (fidelity), whether progress monitoring was conducted correctly, and whether the data supports the school's eligibility conclusion.

This is an underused but legitimate application of IEE rights in Tennessee.

When You Pay Out of Pocket

If you obtain a private evaluation before or without requesting an IEE, or if you choose an evaluator who doesn't meet district criteria and the district won't fund it, you still have the right to present those results to the IEP team for consideration. The team must consider privately obtained evaluations the same way they must consider an IEE — though they are not required to pay for it retroactively.

Private neuropsychological evaluations in Tennessee typically range from $2,000 to $4,000 out of pocket. The IEE process exists precisely so that families don't have to bear that cost to get an independent opinion.

IEE and Due Process

If the district files for due process to defend its evaluation, you are entitled to continue with the IEE at your own expense while the hearing proceeds. If the Administrative Law Judge finds in your favor — determining the school's evaluation was inadequate — the district must fund the IEE.

IEE results are also admissible as evidence in due process hearings. A strong independent evaluation can be the most consequential document in a formal dispute.

The Tennessee IEP & 504 Blueprint includes a section on evaluation rights and templates for written IEE requests — along with guidance on how to prepare for the IEP meeting after you receive independent findings.

The Bottom Line

An IEE is not an aggressive or unusual move. It is a right built into federal law precisely because school evaluations are conducted by the same institution that is financially responsible for providing services. Requesting one does not make you a difficult parent — it makes you an informed one. If the results of your child's school evaluation don't add up, put your request in writing today.

See more United States homeschool guides →