Indiana Choice Scholarship and Special Education: What Happens to Your Child's IEP

Indiana runs one of the largest school voucher programs in the United States. The Choice Scholarship Program has expanded dramatically in recent years, and many families with children who have disabilities see it as an escape hatch from a public school IEP that is not working. What they are rarely told is that using the voucher comes with a legal trade-off that can strip away most of the rights they spent years fighting to secure.

If your child has an IEP and you are considering using an Indiana Choice Scholarship to attend a private or parochial school, you need to understand exactly what changes — and what you give up.

The Core Rule: IEP to CSEP

When a student with a disability uses an Indiana Choice Scholarship to enroll in a participating nonpublic school, the IEP does not transfer. Instead, a completely different document takes its place: the Choice Special Education Plan, or CSEP.

The CSEP is governed by 511 IAC 7-49, which operates under fundamentally different rules than the Article 7 provisions governing public school IEPs. The choice school must convene a meeting within 10 instructional days of enrollment to develop the CSEP. The CSEP must include measurable annual goals and describe the special education services and accommodations to be provided.

That sounds similar to an IEP. The critical difference is in the procedural safeguards — or rather, the absence of them.

What Rights You Lose Under a CSEP

Under a public school IEP, you have the right to dispute substantive decisions about the appropriateness of services through state mediation or a due process hearing before an Independent Hearing Officer. If the school proposes something you disagree with, you can formally challenge it.

Under a CSEP, that right is gone.

A parent's ability to challenge a CSEP is limited strictly to two issues: eligibility (whether the child qualifies for special education at all) and child find (whether the school identified the child as possibly needing special education services). You cannot use Indiana's mediation or due process system to challenge whether the CSEP services are adequate, whether the accommodations are appropriate, or whether the private school is actually delivering what the CSEP specifies.

If the choice school provides two hours per week of speech therapy when your child needs five, and you disagree, you have almost no formal legal recourse within the special education system. Your options are essentially: negotiate with the private school, withdraw from the Choice Scholarship and return to the public school system, or pursue other legal avenues outside of Article 7.

The Service Provider Choice You Must Make Before Enrolling

Before you submit the Choice Scholarship application, you must make a decision that most parents do not know is coming: you must select whether the choice school or the local public school corporation of legal settlement will provide the special education services.

If you select the private school as the service provider: the private school is responsible for providing the services in the CSEP. You have limited enforcement mechanisms if those services are inadequate or not delivered.

If you select the public school as the service provider: the student receives CSEP services delivered by public school personnel, which may mean traveling back to the public school for certain services or having public school staff come to the private school. This preserves somewhat more accountability, but the private school environment and logistics can make this complicated.

This election happens before enrollment, which means it happens before you know whether the arrangement will actually work. Families regularly discover problems only after they are already in the private school system with reduced rights.

Private Schools Can Decline Enrollment Based on Cost

Public schools cannot refuse to enroll a student with a disability. Private schools participating in the Choice Scholarship program can.

Under Indiana's program, a nonpublic school is not legally obligated to provide any special education service that would impose an "undue burden" or "fundamentally alter" the nature of its program. In practical terms, this means private schools can — and do — decline to enroll students whose disabilities require more intensive or costly support than the school is set up to provide.

This is a meaningful risk for families with children who have complex needs. A private school may express enthusiasm during a tour, then discover after the CSEP meeting what services are required, and either decline enrollment or provide significantly less than what the child received under the public IEP.

What a CSEP Does Preserve

The CSEP is not entirely without protections. The private school must:

• Conduct a meeting with parents within 10 instructional days of enrollment
• Develop measurable annual goals
• Provide the agreed-upon services and accommodations
• Give parents the opportunity to participate in the CSEP meeting

If the private school fails to provide the CSEP services at all — not a dispute about adequacy but outright non-delivery — the IDOE has child find obligations that may provide some enforcement pathway. But the enforcement mechanisms are significantly weaker than those available under a public IEP.

Charter Schools Are Different

Charter schools are public schools in Indiana. They are their own local educational agencies (LEAs) and are fully bound by Article 7 and IDEA. A student with a disability attending an Indiana charter school retains all the rights they would have at any other public school, including the full IEP process, Prior Written Notice, and access to state complaint and due process mechanisms.

Do not confuse charter schools with voucher-funded private schools. The legal framework is completely different.

If You Are Already in a Choice School and Having Problems

If your child is already enrolled in a private school using a Choice Scholarship and the CSEP is inadequate, your realistic options include:

• Returning to the public school. The student re-enters the public system with an IEP, and the new district must provide comparable services within 10 instructional days while developing a new IEP.
• Requesting a CSEP review meeting to attempt to negotiate improved services.
• Contacting the IDOE if the private school is failing to deliver the CSEP services entirely (child find enforcement).
• Consulting an attorney about whether the private school's actions create liability under other legal frameworks (Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act or the ADA may apply to some private schools under certain circumstances).

The Bottom Line Before Using a Voucher

The Choice Scholarship can be the right decision for some families, including those whose children have disabilities. But it should be a fully informed decision. The trade-off is real: you are exchanging a legally enforceable IEP with robust dispute rights for a CSEP with significantly reduced protections.

Before applying, ask the private school directly: What special education services do you provide? What happens if my child's CSEP requires more support than you typically offer? Who is responsible for delivering the services — your staff or the public school? What is your process if I disagree with the CSEP?

The answers to those questions will tell you a great deal about whether the placement is likely to work for your child.

For a detailed breakdown of the CSEP process, what to negotiate before signing any CSEP agreement, and how to evaluate whether returning to the public school system makes sense for your family, the Indiana IEP & 504 Advocacy Playbook includes a dedicated section on Choice Scholarship implications for families with children who have disabilities.

See more United States guides →