Alabama School Discipline for Students with Disabilities: What Parents Must Know

A suspension letter arrives in the mail. The school is recommending an alternative school placement. Your child with an IEP is being treated the same way as any general education student — but that is not how the law works.

Students with disabilities in Alabama have specific procedural protections under IDEA that limit how schools can respond to behavioral incidents. These protections exist because Alabama's data shows a persistent and serious problem: students with disabilities — particularly Black students — face disciplinary removals at rates far exceeding their general education peers.

The 10-Day Rule

Before any other calculation, understand the 10-day threshold. Under IDEA and Alabama Administrative Code Chapter 290-8-9, a suspension of 10 or fewer cumulative school days in a school year is generally treated as a short-term removal that does not trigger the full procedural protections.

Once suspensions exceed 10 cumulative school days in a year, or if the district is proposing a disciplinary change of placement (such as long-term suspension, expulsion, or transfer to an alternative school), additional requirements kick in automatically.

This threshold matters because schools sometimes use a pattern of short suspensions — five days here, four days there — that technically stay under the limit individually but add up quickly. Once you exceed 10 days total, the student's full disciplinary rights are in play.

Manifestation Determination Review

When a student with a disability is facing a disciplinary change of placement, the school must hold a Manifestation Determination Review (MDR) within 10 school days. Alabama schools are legally required to conduct this review — it is not optional.

The MDR team — which must include the parent — answers two questions:

1. Was the behavior caused by, or did it have a direct and substantial relationship to, the child's disability?
2. Was the behavior a direct result of the district's failure to implement the IEP?

If the answer to either question is yes, the behavior is a "manifestation" of the disability. The student cannot be expelled. The team must instead:

• Conduct or review a Functional Behavioral Assessment (FBA)
• Implement or revise a Behavioral Intervention Plan (BIP)
• Return the student to their current placement (unless the parent and district agree to a change)

If the answer to both questions is no, the district may proceed with the same disciplinary measures it would use for a student without a disability — but even then, it must continue to provide educational services.

For existing posts on the manifestation determination process specifically, see alabama-manifestation-determination.

Alternative School Placement: What the Law Requires

Alternative educational settings — separate day schools, alternative campuses, homebound programs — are among the most serious placements a district can make. Under Alabama law, placing a student with a disability in an alternative setting is still governed by IDEA.

The district cannot simply assign a student with an IEP to an alternative school the way it might with a general education student. The placement must:

• Go through the IEP team process (not just an administrator's decision)
• Provide a Free Appropriate Public Education in the new setting
• Include the student's current IEP services to the extent the setting allows
• Have a defined timeframe or review process

If the district is proposing an alternative placement as discipline, the MDR must occur first. If the behavior is a manifestation of disability, the alternative placement as a punitive measure is generally prohibited.

Interim alternative educational settings (up to 45 school days) are permitted without an MDR in cases involving weapons, drugs, or serious bodily injury — but even in these cases, the district must provide educational services and an FBA.

Alabama's Restraint and Seclusion Law

Alabama passed Act 2019-465, which fundamentally changed how physical intervention can be used in schools. This law:

• Categorically prohibits seclusion in all Alabama public schools
• Prohibits mechanical and chemical restraints
• Allows physical restraint only when the student poses an immediate danger to themselves or others
• Requires written notification to parents within one school day of any restraint incident
• Requires a formal debriefing with staff after any restraint

If your child has been restrained and you were not notified in writing within one school day, the school violated state law. Document the incident and send a written request for the debriefing report and the notification records.

The School-to-Prison Pipeline in Alabama

Alabama data consistently shows that Black students with disabilities face the most severe disciplinary consequences. Analysis of state educational data has found that Black students were nearly twice as likely to face classroom removals as their white counterparts. For students with unaddressed emotional and behavioral disabilities, frequent suspensions and alternative school placements become a direct pipeline into the juvenile justice system.

The Southern Poverty Law Center has been actively litigating Alabama cases involving discriminatory school discipline and has secured individual relief for students wrongly excluded from their educational placements. The Alabama Disabilities Advocacy Program (ADAP) also prioritizes cases involving the school-to-prison pipeline, particularly for students of color with disabilities.

Under IDEA, the ALSDE monitors local districts for "significant disproportionality" in discipline — Indicators 9 and 10 of the State Performance Plan. Districts identified as significantly disproportionate must redirect 15% of their IDEA Part B funds toward early intervention services. If your district has been identified, it is a signal that systemic problems exist and that your individual advocacy may have additional support from state oversight.

What to Do When Discipline Feels Wrong

If your child with an IEP is facing serious discipline:

1. Request the MDR in writing immediately. Do not wait for the school to schedule it. Email the principal and special education coordinator: "I am requesting a Manifestation Determination Review for [child's name] within the required 10 school days."

2. Request all records. Ask for the disciplinary incident report, any behavioral data from the classroom, and your child's current IEP — specifically the behavioral supports and BIP if one exists.

3. Document the meeting. Bring a notepad. Write down who said what. Follow up every verbal statement with a written confirmation email.

4. Do not sign anything you do not agree with. If the team concludes the behavior was not a manifestation and you disagree, you have the right to contest that finding through mediation or due process.

5. Request Prior Written Notice of any proposed change in placement, including the alternative school.

The Alabama IEP & 504 Advocacy Playbook at /us/alabama/advocacy/ includes communication templates specifically designed for discipline situations — from requesting an MDR to documenting restraint incidents and filing state complaints when the district fails to follow the law.

Discipline crises move fast. The paperwork you establish in the first 48 hours determines what tools you have available a week later.

See more United States guides →